Fun With the BCS and College Football Realignment
Here's my plan to make college football more fair. Keep in mind I paid absolutely no attention to current TV contracts, the wishes of university presidents or bowl committees, basketball or logic. Those things tend to get in the way of what's right for the greatest sport on earth. I think my plan makes college football a better product. And it gives us a better national championship.
Conference Realignment
First up are the conferences. The ACC, SEC, Big 12 and MAC stay the same. Notre Dame joins the Big Ten to give it 12 teams and a conference championship game.
| East | West |
| Indiana | Illinois |
| Michigan | Iowa |
| Michigan State | Minnesota |
| Ohio State | Northwestern |
| Penn State | Notre Dame |
| Purdue | Wisconsin |
The Pac 10 adds BYU and Utah to give it 12 teams and a championship game.
| North | South |
| BYU | Arizona |
| Oregon | Arizona State |
| Oregon State | Cal |
| Utah | Stanford |
| Washington | UCLA |
| Washington State | USC |
The Big East adds UCF, East Carolina, Marshall and Western Kentucky to give it (that's right) 12 teams and a championship game.
| North | South |
| Connecticut | Central Florida |
| Marshall | Cincinnati |
| Pittsburgh | East Carolina |
| Rutgers | Louisville |
| Syracuse | South Florida |
| West Virginia | Western Ky. |
The Mountain West loses its two strongest members, but gets the best from the WAC and two teams from C-USA. It's still not as good as the nine-team Mountain West that included BYU and Utah, but it does have 12 teams and a championship game and could become the seventh BCS conference. Yes, I realize I didn't move Hawaii to the new Mountain West. But with the travel costs associated with including Hawaii and the inevitable downturn the Warriors will face without June Jones, I decided to include SMU instead.
| East | West |
| Air Force | Boise State |
| Colorado State | Fresno State |
| New Mexico | Nevada |
| SMU | UNLV |
| TCU | San Diego State |
| UTEP | Wyoming |
C-USA gets screwed, just like it did five years ago when the Big East had to fill in its empty spaces. However, it becomes a junior SEC and more of a regional southeast conference. Oh, and it still has 12 teams and a championship game.
| East | West |
| UAB | Arkansas State |
| Memphis | Houston |
| Middle Tenn. | Louisiana Tech |
| Southern Miss | North Texas |
| Troy | Rice |
| Tulane | Tulsa |
This gives us nine conferences with at least 12 teams and a conference title game and nine teams spread throughout the country that inhabit the remnants of the Sun Belt and WAC as well as Army and Navy.
The National Championship
Now for deciding the national champion. We have six 12-team conferences with automatic bids into our new BCS. They are joined by six at-large teams, at least one of which must come from a non-BCS conference. We then inact the plus-one system.
The Cotton Bowl and Holiday Bowl are added to the BCS mix to give us six BCS bowls to host our 12 teams. Those 12 teams are the only teams that are eligible to compete in the BCSCG, which will be held the Saturday before the Super Bowl.
All bowl games, BCS and otherwise, have to be completed by Jan. 2 (if Jan. 1 falls on a Sunday). After those games are played, we run the BCS rankings again to get our two teams for the BCSCG which will rotate between the Cotton, Holiday, Orange, Sugar, Fiesta and Rose Bowls.
Doing this gives fans of the two BCSCG teams enough time to make travel arrangements and ESPN enough time to hype the shit out of it.
If You Disagree With Me You Must be a Communist
So there you have it. This is the best way to fix college football. Realign the conferences, add two bowl games to the BCS and have a plus-one national championship. It gives the little guys a chance, keeps the regular season meaningful, keeps the bowls happy and gives the fans ample time to get to a national title game.
It gives the little guys a chance by including them on the BCS. It keeps the bowls happy because six of them have an impact on possibly deciding the national championship instead of one. And it benefits the fan by giving them nearly a month to get to that BCSCG at the end, which is MUCH better than a playoff.
This makes college football a better product and in my opinion would make it more money than it already does (imagine the hype and coverage leading up to championship weekend). Now if we can just get that conference realignment going.
8 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Santas a commie /Seinfelded
Nice post F4H. The only thing I don’t like is including all the teams. I like how the BCS represents tradition and pits the big boys against each other. Not that Utah, Boise State, etc aren’t worthy but everyone would much rather have two traditional programs play on New Year’s Day. TV ratings have spoke to that. I don’t like how the BCS governs the MNC, and excludes teams. The more I think about the problem there needs to be two systems, one that determines who plays for the title (4 team tourney) and another that pairs up the big money bowl games. The idea is half baked right now mostly because I am running on caffeine.
But then you look at the beauty of the +1 and can just say yeah that will work too.
Alcohol is my anti-drug. CollegeGameBalls.com
by collegegameballs on Jul 30, 2009 11:49 AM EDT reply actions
Erm...
If you’re blowing things up and moving things around for georgraphical reasons and are unconcerned with TV contracts and other financial reasons, then as a Big East guy, I’ve got to say this alignment is a bit strange in places …
- Why aren’t Penn State and BC in the Big East? Why is USF?
- UCF is a plausible add to the Big East if you’re keeping USF, and ECU is plausible if you’re trying to get the Big East up to 12 without disrupting the ACC or Big Ten. But Marshall and Western Kentucky? Really? I mean, the “usual suspects” for Big East expansion are ECU, UCF, and Memphis with good reason (along with loony plans involving the service academies, Notre Dame, BC, and, mostly, Penn State), and there are a heck of a lot of northeastern and midwestern MAC schools that are better than Marshall and WKY.
Also
- The MAC currently has 13 teams, not 12
- Why SMU instead of Tulsa if you’re cherry-picking CUSA West teams to fill out the MWC?
Here’s what I did with a somewhat more radical slicing and dicing, still on the 12-team model: http://cusefaninsocal.blogspot.com/2008/12/radical-realignment-take-i.html
… though I liked the ten-team model better: http://cusefaninsocal.blogspot.com/2008/12/radical-realignment-take-ii.html
.. and the more I thought about it, the more I liked the fifteen 8-team conferences and a 32-team playoff model: http://cusefaninsocal.blogspot.com/2009/03/radical-realignment-take-iii.html
Re: MAC
notice i said nine conferences with at least 12 teams. at no point in my post did i insinuate that the mac had less than 13 teams.
everything else was done because i felt like it. why did i put marshall and western kentucky in the big east? because i don’t like the big east, west virginia or louisville and having mu and wku in the big east would piss off fans of all three.
and as for conference size, nine teams is a lot better than 10 or eight because then you get a balanced schedule with four home and away conference games. the way the big east and pac 10 does things is cute and all, but the fans of half of the teams aren’t going to be happy with it every year.
A bullhorn, a bottle of whiskey and a dream. GobblerCountry.com
by furrer4heisman on Aug 6, 2009 10:45 AM EDT up reply actions
Except that 120 isn't divisible by 9
… which kind of causes the whole thing to blow up with nine-team conferences. I mean, you can try to build things by leaving the service academies and independents (or Army, Navy, and ND), but that doesn’t really work in a conference champion-centric playoff structure.
and what happens if teams from i-aa want to join i-a? then your model gets screwed up again anyway.
A bullhorn, a bottle of whiskey and a dream. GobblerCountry.com
by furrer4heisman on Aug 6, 2009 8:57 PM EDT up reply actions
Can't
The NCAA has a moratorium on schools moving up right now. Western Kentucky was the last one they allowed.
doesn’t mean they cant join five years from now.
A bullhorn, a bottle of whiskey and a dream. GobblerCountry.com
by furrer4heisman on Aug 7, 2009 3:53 PM EDT up reply actions

by 












