2010 Virginia Tech Depth Chart Debates: Running Back
We continue our look at next season's depth chart with a look at the position with the most talent to spare. In the last two seasons a different Tech running back has sent the ACC freshman single-season rushing record. This past year, Ryan Williams didn't just fill in admirably for Darren Evans, he broke the Hokies' single-season rushing record.
Now the Hokies have to find a way to keep both Williams and Evans happy as well as find time to pass the ball every now and then to keep defenses honest. Let's take a more complete look at the position and then let you discuss how to best distribute carries and what on earth we're supposed to do with Josh Oglesby and David Wilson.
Running Back
Starter: Ryan Williams, So. (returning starter)
Possible Backups: Darren Evans, Jr.; Josh Oglesby, Jr.; David Wilson, So.
Outlook: The Hokies will go into 2010 with the best backfield in the ACC. However, as we learned with Clemson in 2008, they'll only go as far as their offensive line will take them. The Hokies have received excellent run blocking in recent years, but have to replace left guard Sergio Render. If they can do that and the holes are there, Williams and Evans will find them without problem. Right now I have Williams as the starter because we don't know yet how Darren Evans' knee will react when he gets back to football speed. So until then, Williams is the guy.
After those two, things get hazy. Oglesby backed up Evans in 2008 and Williams in 2009. Every year in spring and fall practice we hear about how Oglesby has turned a corner. Well, it seems that he may just be a practice all-star because his in-game performance has never lived up to the hype. Barring another injury (knock on all different kinds of wood) I doubt he'll get many significant carries in 2010. It may be time for Oglesby to find another position like Justin Hamilton did or make his way to I-AA.
If Oglesby decides to stick it out at running back and be our mop-up duty guy, then David Wilson should probably redshirt. He's probably the fastest in the stable of backs, but with the logjam at both running back and flanker, he probably won't get any touches outside of special teams. My guess is at the end of the 2010 season either Williams or Evans or both will jump to the NFL. That will clear things up for the speedy Wilson in 2011, but he may want to consider sitting out the upcoming year.
If you're wondering about Kenny Lewis, a return from the torn left Achilles tendon he suffered against Western Kentucky in 2008 is unlike. Complications, including the dreaded staph infection, and multiple surgeries likely mean Lewis' career at Virginia Tech is over. Lewis is a team leader and a guy the rest of the team looks up to so his leadership qualities will be missed.
Up for Debate
- Who should start? Williams or Evans?
- What percentage of carries should Evans get?
- Should Josh Oglesby stick it out, change positions or transfer?
- Should David Wilson redshirt?
0 recs |
8 comments
|
Comments
I wanted to click 1000%
but the option wasn’t there.
You are a sad, strange little man, and you have my pity.
Williams Starts
I’d give Evans 30% of the carries in ’10. Wilson should redshirt. RW will go pro after next year guaranteed (barring an offseason injury). Then Evans and Wilson can split in ’11.
I really thought Oglesby did a good job as a backup this year. He seemed to really learn how to come in and make himself a productive backup. I have no clue what he should do next year though.
My opinion
Ryan Wiliams starts and Darren Evans is his backup. I think Oglesby should stick it out he’s useful pass catching out of the backfield. David Wilson redshirts. Hopefully we can keep all four.
ARE YOU GUYS CRAZY? I'm talking about you furrer4heisman and BirdGT!
WHAT DO YOU MEAN JOSH OGLESBY DIDN’T IMPRESS!? ARE YOU NUTS!? When do we hear EVERY YEAR that he has turned a corner. He’s only been at Tech for 3 years, one of which he redshirted (and I’m sure that was never a topic of discussion with Beamer, because no one would bother to ask him about how a redshirted running back who was ABSOLUTELY buried on the depth chart was progressing), another of which he came into the season as the third, maybe even the fourth back behind Cheeseman, and because he hadn’t played to that point, it is very unlikely anyone would think to ask “Has Josh Oglesby turned a corner with his game?,”or that Beamer would just bring it up out of the blue when nobody outside of the program had seen him play, and then there was ‘09, where Oglesby was the Hokies BEST at pass protection in the backfield, and went from 88 yards on 38 carries to 335 yards on 78 carries and two CRUCIAL touchdowns that made sure we weren’t upset by Duke. I don’t know what universe you live in, but not respecting Oglesby and his effort (think Dustin Pickle but with more physical talent) is just sorry. Also, by all accounts, Oglesby has THE BEST set of hands on the team. So while it might make sense to move him to another position based on that, he is pretty exclusively a running back in my mind. I think that we should redshirt Wilson to prevent more logjam and to prevent him from jumping to the NFL as well, but Oglesby (provided he stays) will be among the best third-string running backs IN THE NATION! He runs just as hard as those two guys ahead of him, and based on their penchant for running hard, that’s a very good compliment. And BirdGT, what the hell are you talking about!? Are you insane? I like Daron Evans, but Ryan Williams is a special talent the likes of which we’ve never seen. Darren Evans comparatively is a poor man’s Lee Suggs. I like him, but he should get no more than 35% of the carries provided only Williams is getting the other touches. Otherwise, that number should be less. And yes, provided he stays healthy Ryan Williams will jump to the NFL next year, it’s a given. But I don’t see Evans ever being able to make that jump early. You could argue with me, but I just don’t think he translates as an every down back in the NFL. Think a smaller, slower Brandon Jacobs when you think NFL comparisons. His speed is not gonna cut in the NFL. He may be drafted, but I think regardless of the stats he puts up in college that the NFL scouts will see through that. Having said that, I WANT him to succeed, I’m just being a realist and I don’t see it. Final point: After all this, it will suffice to say we are going to have an absolutely NASTY backfield next year. Just hope we can score a lot of points to help out that defense that will be SOOOOOOOOO green.
Whoops
Haha. I saw the GT part, but I don’t get the Bird part. And yes, I found the Darren Evans mishap you were speaking of. My bad. But if you’ll look, I spelled it correctly earlier in the article. In my defense, one of my best friends and colleagues is named Daron. Still, I’ve got a point. 2 in fact.
Mix it Up
I got an idea that maybe our OC should think about… Since it seems that everyone has forgotten just how much of a stud D. Evans was last season, why not come up with some plays that involve having Tyrod, RW, and Evans all in the backfield at the same time? Defenses would not know what to do especially with Boykin and Coales lined up at wide out too! I think it would be interesting to see RW and Evans lined up as split backs with Tyrod either under center or in the shotgun. There are so many creative and traditional plays that could be run out of this formation. Not saying that this needs to be our primary offense, but it definetely should be considered! And we could still have Oglesby to step in occasionally to rest them both from time to time. I agree with Chicago, Oglesby will definetely be one of the best third string RB’s in the nation next year. Oh, and hopefully they will redshirt Wilson, I think that would the best situation for him… Bottom line all of our skill positions are gonna be stacked next year, we just need to think about replacing some key o-linemen and defensive players such as Grimm and Worilds, why couldnt he wait one more year to go pro!!!?….

by 




















