Should Virginia Tech RB Ryan Williams Play Against NC State?
Hokies running back Ryan Williams returned to practice Monday and could play Saturday at NC State. His official status for the game won't be known until Virginia Tech releases its injury report on Thursday. If Williams does play, he may not be 100 percent, as the Washington Post's Mark Giannotto observed:
Perhaps the most telling part of the session came at the end, when Williams ran wind sprints with his teammates. The Manassas native did not run with the running backs, instead taking it easy by doing his set of sprints with the lineman group. Even while jogging, though, it appeared Williams was favoring his right leg slightly.
Without Williams, Hokies' running backs David Wilson and Darren Evans were held to 97 yards on 30 carries (3.2 ypc). This week they'll face a Wolfpack team that held its first three opponents under three yards per carry and held Georgia Tech to nearly 100 yards below its season average.
The question is: If Williams isn't 100 percent, should he see the field against the Wolfpack?
The argument for playing Williams against NC State is that it's a big conference game and the Hokies need him. If he tweaks his hamstring again, he'll have over a month to rest for Tech's next big game against Georgia Tech Nov. 4. Between NC State and GT, the Hokies face Central Michigan, Wake Forest and Duke at home and then have a bye week.
I think Williams shouldn't play because of NC State's defense. It's a blitzing, attacking defense that sends middle linebacker Nate Irving into the opposing team's backfield with regularity. With the current state of our offensive line, I don't think Williams could be effective if he played. I think he should stay out another week and then be eased back into the lineup the next three games against lesser opponents.
We will need Williams for the tough November stretch against GT, North Carolina and Miami. We shouldn't risk getting him hurt more than he already is if he isn't completely healed.
7 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Why risk it?
While the NC State game is big, I’d rather have RMFW healthy for the GT/UNC/UM divisional stretch.
Best Thing Against ECU
Sorry to say but the best thing that happened for our offense in the ECU game was Ryan Williams going down. Only then did we get our running game going. Reason? No clue. Could be many different things. But why put him back in unless he’s 100%.
Agreed
Whether Tech uses RMFW, Evans, Wilson, Kevin Jones, Lee Suggs, etc… it won’t matter if the O-line doesn’t iron out the bugs. If the O-line creates some holes, I have plenty of confidence that Evans and Wilson have the toughness and speed to burst thru for some big runs.
Definitely sit him and let him ease back into form. Maybe if things fall into place with his health and the O-line we’ll start seeing 2009-type highlight reel plays for the second half of the season.
Even with that kind of O line play (who knows if its poor coaching),
Stiney can figure out something more creative than run up the middle . Three top notch RB’s can be used in many ways regardless of the OL, but we do not use such creativity running up the gut is so much more imaginative an hard to predict.
Agree with the O-line comments
There is zero difference in who is running the ball for VT as long as the run blocking is as awful as it’s been in the three of the first four games. ECU was the exception that proves the rule: right now, the Hokies can’t run against any defense with a pulse.
That's not what I asked.
I should SHOULD he play, not WILL he play. I know what you said earlier this week.
A bullhorn, a bottle of whiskey and a dream. Gobbler Country | Twitter | Facebook
by furrer4heisman on Sep 28, 2010 11:36 PM EDT up reply actions

by 
















