Virginia Tech Football: Examining A Pair Of Pundits Selections For Their All-ACC Teams

Bob Donnan-USA TODAY Sports

All of these will be wrong by November, but we take a look at what we think these publications got right and where they erred. And one egregious omission almost causes me to lose all respect.

It's June, so it's time for the college football pundits to bridge this interminable void by spewing hot air that will mostly be proven incorrect by late November.  Nonetheless, it's a good time to kind of take stock of teams' inventories that are presently frozen, with no practice to inflict injury and position competitions that might unseat starters still on the horizon.

Today we are focusing on notable personnel from around the ACC, and examining two publications' excuses for their 2014 All-ACC teams. My childhood favorite, Athlon's Magazine (SO GLOSSY!) and Phil Steele, who has made a name for himself by being one of the more accurate prognosticators from time to time. Which proves nothing, as Sidney Deane once tried to remind Billy Ho:

Wesley_snipes_medium

Without further ado, let's take a look at what Phil had to say about this year's Hokie team within the context of the ACC. Here is his table:

Phil Steele's 2014 Preseason All-ACC Team

OFFENSE

1st TEAM 2nd TEAM 3rd TEAM 4th TEAM
QB Jameis Winston, Florida St Marquise Williams, North Carolina Anthony Boone, Duke Will Gardner, Louisville
RB Duke Johnson, Miami Kevin Parks, Virginia Dominique Brown, Louisville TJ Logan, North Carolina
RB Karlos Williams, Florida St Trey Edmunds, Virginia Tech James Conner, Pittsburgh Wayne Gallman, Clemson
WR Rashad Greene, Florida St Tyler Boyd, Pittsburgh Eli Rogers, Louisville Charone Peake, Clemson
WR Jamison Crowder, Duke Quinshad Davis, North Carolina Phillip Dorsett, Miami Demitri Knowles, Va Tech
WR DeVante Parker, Louisville Stacy Coley, Miami Joshua Stanford, Va Tech Isaiah Jones, Florida St
TE Nick O'Leary, Florida St Braxton Deaver, Duke Gerald Christian, Louisville Clive Walford, Miami
C Jake Smith, Louisville Andy Gallik, Boston College Shane McDermott, Miami David Wang, Virginia Tech
OG Tre' Jackson Florida St Josue Matias, Florida St John Miller, Louisville Landon Turner, N Carolina
OG Laken Tomlinson, Duke Shaquille Mason, Georgia Tech Matt Rotheram, Pittsburgh Bobby Vardaro, Boston Coll
OT Sean Hickey, Syracuse Ereck Flowers, Miami Jamon Brown, Louisville Tyson Chandler, NC State
OT Cameron Erving, Florida St Bobby Hart, Florida St Jonathan McLaughlin, Va Tech Takoby Cofield, Duke
DEFENSE

1st TEAM 2nd TEAM 3rd TEAM 4th TEAM
DE Vic Beasley, Clemson Lorenzo Mauldin, Louisville Corey Crawford, Clemson Chris Casher, Florida St
DT Grady Jarrett, Clemson Eddie Goldman, Florida St Adam Gotsis, Georgia Tech Andrew Brown, Virginia
DT Luther Maddy, Virginia Tech Thomas Teal, NC State David Dean, Virginia Corey Marshall, Virginia Tech
DE Mario Edwards, Florida St Anthony Chickillo, Miami Eli Harold, Virginia Art Norman, NC State
LB Denzel Perryman, Miami Norkeithus Otis, North Carolina Cameron Lynch, Syracuse Reggie Northrup, Florida St
LB Stephone Anthony, Clemson Quayshawn Nealy, Georgia Tech Henry Coley, Virginia James Burgess, Louisville
LB Kelby Brown, Duke Dyshawn Davis, Syracuse Steven Daniels, Boston Coll Anthony Gonzalez, Pittsburgh
LB Terrance Smith, Florida St David Helton, Duke Travis Hughes, North Carolina Tony Steward, Clemson
CB Kendall Fuller, Virginia Tech Ronald Darby, Florida St Kevin Johnson, Wake Forest Tracy Howard, Miami
CB PJ Williams, Florida St Brandon Facyson, Virginia Tech Charles Gaines, Louisville Demetrious Nicholson, UVA
S Anthony Harris, Virginia Kyshoen Jarrett, Virginia Tech Jayron Kearse, Clemson Tim Scott, North Carolina
S Jeremy Cash, Duke Durell Eskridge, Syracuse Jalen Ramsey, Florida St Isaiah Johnson, Georgia Tech
SPECIAL TEAMS

1st TEAM 2nd TEAM 3rd TEAM 4th TEAM
K Roberto Aguayo, Florida St Niklas Sade, NC State John Wallace, Louisville Ross Krautman, Syracuse
P Tommy Hibbard, North Carolina Will Monday, Duke AJ Hughes, Virginia Tech Wil Baumann, NC State
KR Kermit Whitfield, Florida St DeVon Edwards, Duke Charles Gaines, Louisville TJ Logan, North Carolina
PR Ryan Switzer, North Carolina Jamison Crowder, Duke Stacy Coley, Miami Adam Humphries, Clemson


OFFENSE: Understandably no Hokie QBs. What number ranking All-ACC team would our QB make right this minute? Nobody can even say. This scares me, but it excites me also. We might have hit the transfer lottery with Michael Brewer, and then again we might be looking at Mark Leal or Brendan Motley in which case VT would have the 10th or 11th team All-ACC QB at best.

At RB, Trey Edmunds as a 2nd teamer could definitely be a possibility. He had a promising year behind an up-and-down line. But will he come back from that broken leg he suffered against UVA without trepidation in order to run his hardest in August? He will need to because Juice is coming. By Juice, I'm sure you know I mean true freshman Marshawn Williams, who could easily wind up on one of these teams at the end of the season if he's granted enough carries.

It's no surprise that we didn't have a Tight End named, but we have a couple who will be productive. Fact is, these teams that have an All-ACC TE all emphasize that role in the passing game whereas we use the TEs more sparingly.

Stanfordsouthpark_medium

Steele thinks very highly of the young wide receivers, and he should. If Demetri Knowles could ever match the right pace with his QB's arm strength, he'd be such the vertical weapon. But with his hands still developing, and maybe no longer focusing so much on what he's doing playbook-wise, he can finally make plays consistently. 4th team is a nice safe hedge bet for a veteran like him. The other WR, South Park #5 (Joshua Stanford) is primed for a breakout season. Had Logan Thomas had one more year, his rapport with Stanford might have been scary.  Though he only scored one TD, he hauled in 40 receptions for 16 yards a catch, including several third down, drive-extending receptions. It would be tough for Stanford to crack the top two teams, with Duke's Crowder and FSU's Greene and UNC's Davis all excellent players. With three years left though, he has the opportunity to be VT's first 1,000 yard WR.

Rounding out the offensive selections are VT's  linemen, OT Jon McLaughlin and C David Wang. Big Jon's third team status is about right, but I could see him being a first team talent if he took the next step mentally. He's nimble for his size, and his football IQ just needed to catch up to his strength/bulk. If that has happened, the Hokies will be strong running to the left this year. As for Wang, will he even hold down a starting spot? That plus the fact he has battled injuries throughout his entire tenure makes his nod slightly suspect. I think Phil Steele is giving the Wang family a nod, he just remembered Ed, and thought *legacy*.

HALFTIME SCORE:

His picks, Phil Steele.

My breakdown?

Valyrian_steel_medium

DEFENSE: If you can't look at the defensive selections and IMMEDIATELY tell me what's wrong you haven't been paying attention. Did Phil Steele take a dare in leaving Dadi Nicolas off the team? The second team would have been fair to him, although I would have accepted third team, as he hasn't started enough. As I put it, this is an egregious omission, and it undermines the credibility of every word Phil Steele ever puts to paper for ever more.

Luther Maddy is going to be a First-Team All American this year. The oracle has spoken. He is dominant whenever he wants to be. Will he want it every down though? Corey Marshall is getting a lot of respect from Steele with his 4th team selection for having not played last year. Part of me wonders if Steele began to get drowsy as he researched the teams at the end of the alphabet and transposed Marshall and Nicolas. Nobody here would be surprised if all three wound up taking home end-of-year honors.

I am thinking about running a contest (for a free GC tee-shirt) to see if anyone can correctly predict our two deep at the LB spots going into summer practice. If its that much of a mystery to us here, there is no way Phil Steele would even entertain naming one of our LBs to these teams. Plenty of room for this unit to shock the world that's for sure. Nobody will see it coming.

And onto the new incarnation of Pride and Joy, our D-block. Kendall Fuller and Brendan Facyson are 1st and 2nd team respectively. I'm good with this, although had Facsyon not gotten injured and missed time last year, he and Fuller could have set a school record for combined interceptions by a pair of Hokies cornerbacks. The surprise to me is Kyshoen Jarrett also earning a second team nod. A streaky player, Jarrett can be on the good end of several plays in short sequence and then lose complete focus on the next series. He hammers guys though, and makes it tough on any ball carrier even if I wish his ball skills were better.

And since we are on the subject of safety play, if Jarrett made second team, who's holding him back from being a first team All-ACC safety? None other than UVA's Anthony Harris, who returned from his first-half suspension (served against the Hokies) for targeting Miami QB Stephen Morris and immediately hit one of our guys out of bounds. Not only he is a late hitter, but hiz skillz are suspect, son. Bask in the glory of this come-from-ahead UVA (v Miami 2012) loss wherein Harris plays the part of "Toast":

Laughable, and even in that game he's horse-collaring guys who have gotten a step on him. I look forward to welcoming Harris the day after Thanksgiving this year as we begin the second "Decade of Dominance."

Finally, we have Mr Hughes, our reliable Punter. I'm starting to get worried that I'm starting to relate to Oakland Raiders fans who for years turned up at the O Coliseum to watch Shane Lechler and Sebastian Janikowski kick. "Yep, we're struggling offensively, but have you seen our P? He's a perennial pro-bowler!". I must take some umbrage with the notion that there are two better punters than AJ in the league. Though if you did choose two, its appropriate that they come from Carolina and Dook.

Athlon's

First here's the link, couldn't get the chart to format, sorry: http://athlonsports.com/college-football/acc-football-2014-all-conference-team

I'll just run though Athlon's real quick with a few quick comparisons and thoughts:

4th team Offense: OT Jon McLaughlin ....yep that's it for offense folks, apparently Athlon DOES NOT SMELL WHAT THE ROCK LOEFFLER IS COOKING. Almost completely bereft of Hokies, which indicates that Athlon's likely thinks we don't have but one player they would deign Top 50.

And you know what folks? A pessimist might see it that way too. I'm likely somewhere in between their assessment and Steele's above. I would feel confident awarding Big Jon, Edmunds, and Stanford...not Knowles or Wang though.

1st team Defense: DT Luther Maddy and CB Kendall Fuller .....no quarrel from me here. Same as Steele's.

2nd team Defense: CB Brandon Facsyon ....again, well-deserved.

3rd team Defense: DE Dadi Nicolas and S Kyshoen Jarrett... finally a little wisdom. Even without the offense sending anyone to their teams, I'm about to award Athlon the win here. The Nicolas question was worth half the exam!

And finally....pride and joy....the honor of honors:

1st team Specialist: P AJ Hughes... feel the excitement! The exhilaration is unparalleled. See for yourself. Nothing like putting it inside the 10 after another stalled drive just inside the opponent's 50.

Hopefully you found this a decent way to pass the time while we wait for the days to shorten. Let us know what you think of the selections/omissions in the comments below, and have a super Father's Day weekend, it's shaping up to be epic. We're supposed to have good pool weather (in DC), the US Open, the World Cup, the Heat losing not one, not two, Ok maybe just two NBA championship series'  and the Game of Thrones Season Four Finale. I may need to take Monday off to recover from all the relaxation.

X
Log In Sign Up

forgot?
Log In Sign Up

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior users will need to choose a permanent username, along with a new password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

I already have a Vox Media account!

Verify Vox Media account

Please login to your Vox Media account. This account will be linked to your previously existing Eater account.

Please choose a new SB Nation username and password

As part of the new SB Nation launch, prior MT authors will need to choose a new username and password.

Your username will be used to login to SB Nation going forward.

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Gobbler Country

You must be a member of Gobbler Country to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Gobbler Country. You should read them.

Join Gobbler Country

You must be a member of Gobbler Country to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Gobbler Country. You should read them.

Spinner.vc97ec6e

Authenticating

Great!

Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.

tracking_pixel_9347_tracker